United States Customs Court January 15, 1960, Reap. Dec. 9581 (Plywood & Door Manufacturers Corp. v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1960

Mollison, Judge:

These are appeals for reappraisement of the values returned by the United States appraisers at the ports of New York and Baltimore on certain birch plywood, exported from Finland during the period between June 8, 1954, and April 23, 1955. Two of the appeals, namely, reappraisements 280813-A and 280824r-A, involve shipments of plywood in panels or sheets of certain inch sizes, *543ranging from 48 x 30 x y2 to 84 x 50 x 1. For convenience, these will be referred to as the “panel” cases.

The other two appeals, namely, reappraisements 291144 — A and 291746-A, involve shipments of so-called plywood “bedrails,” being 76 x 4% x i%6 or 76 x 5 x i%6 inches. For convenience, these will be referred to as the “bedrail” cases.

The merchandise involved in the panel cases was appraised on the basis of foreign value (defined in section 402(c), Tariff Act of 1930, as amended), while that in the bedrail cases was appraised on the basis of export value (defined in section 402(d) of the said act). Plaintiff contends that the correct basis of value in each case is export value and that the correct export values in each case are lower than the values returned by the appraisers.

On the motion of counsel for the plaintiff, the panel and bedrail cases were consolidated for trial and disposition together because there are certain portions of the evidence applicable to both forms of plywood.

With respect to the basis of value of the merchandise in the panel cases, plaintiff’s claim that the correct basis of value should be export value is based upon its contention that, at the time of exportation of the involved shipments, merchandise such as or similar to the plywood .involved in those cases was not offered or sold for home consumption in Finland.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.