District Court, E.D. New York February 16, 1960, Civ. A. 18898 (Andretta v. Tube Distributors Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-02-1960
BYERS, District Judge.
This is a motion by a third-party defendant to dismiss the third-party complaint, for failure to give notice of claim within the time specified in the policy involved; or in the alternative, to grant a severance as to the third-party action.
The dispute is obviously between two liability companies that insured the defendant Tube, and Eazor respectively.
The plaintiff Andretta was an employee of the latter on July 2, 1957 and asserts that he was injured at about 11:40 “while walking on top of crates of merchandise stowed on his truck, tripped on some of the merchandise and fell off the truck to the ground.” (Pretrial conference May 19, 1959.)
He brought suit against Tube and in his complaint, filed July 29, 1958, alleged :
“2. On July 2, 1957, the plaintiff was an invitee on the premises of defendant’s place of business in Garden City, New York.
“3. At the said time and place, the defendant through its agents, servants or employees so negligently operated a crane as to cause plaintiff to fall and suffer injury.”
An answer was filed August 26, 1958 denying the above quoted allegations and pleading as a defense contributory negligence.
On December 2, 1959 the plaintiff brought its motion for leave to implead its employee Schlapa who was operating the crane referred to in paragraph 3 of the complaint quoted above. That motion was denied by Judge Abruzzo for reasons stated in his opinion of December 22, 1959.
Meanwhile, on June 22, 1959 on unopposed motion, Judge Smith, sitting in this court, signed an order granting Tube’s motion to add Nationwide Insurance Company, the liability insurer of plaintiff’s employer Eazor, to be called Nationwide, as third-party defendant. (Seemingly the correct corporate name is Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company.) Such complaint was filed July 1, 1959, and the answer thereto on September 21, 1959.
The motion to dismiss presents two-important contentions:
A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit