District Court, E.D. Arkansas December 27, 1960, No. J 60 C 26 (Settlemoir v. Flemming)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-12-1960

YOUNG, District Judge.

This appeal was instituted by the claimant from an adverse decision by the referee rendered pursuant to the Federal Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance Benefits Act, 42 U.S.C.A. §§ 401-425. The referee held that Oran Settlemoir and his son, Charles R. Settle-moir, were operating “Settlemoir’s. Grocery” as partners. Pursuant to this conclusion the claimant was entitled to be credited with one-half of the net proceeds of the store for the period 1951 through 1956 for the purpose of determining his net earnings from self-employment. The social security payments to the claimant were reduced in accord with the opinion and claimant appealed.

The issue before this court is whether the decision of the referee is supported by substantial evidence, 42 U.S.C.A. § 405(g), and more particularly whether there is substantial evidence to support the conclusion that claimant and his son were partners. It is the conclusion of the court that the decision is supported by substantial evidence and the referee’s determination is therefore affirmed.

For the calendar years 1951 to 1956 inclusive, the claimant, Oran Settlemoir, filed individual tax returns listing his son, Charles, as a dependant. The claimant also reported his self-employment income for social security purposes as an individual.

On May 10, 1956 the claimant signed a partnership questionnaire, which stated that he and his son were operating the Settlemoir’s Grocery as a partnership, and detailed the methods of conducting the business. On August 21, 1957 Charles Settlemoir in an interview corroborated the version given by his father in regard to the partnership here in question. On January 15, 1958 the claimant signed a statement during an interview with a representative of the Bureau of Old-Age and Survivors Insurance of the Social Security Administration that he and his son were partners in “Settlemoir’s Grocery”.

On January 16, 1958, after consulting with James K.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.