Washington Supreme Court April 27, 1961, 35522 (State v. Turner)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-04-1961

Foster, J.

Turner appeals from convictions and sentence on five counts of first degree and one count of second degree arson.

Two claims are made. Both are without merit.

The appellant claims that a “confession” was improperly admitted in evidence. The admission, erroneously characterized as a “confession,” came in the testimony of Captain Gillespie respecting a conversation with the appellant on the night he was apprehended. When appellant told Gilles

*160

pie that he did not know where he was when the fires occurred, Gillespie responded by saying that appellant could not then deny setting the fires.

1

A confession is a statement by a person “ ‘. . . wherein he acknowledges himself to be guilty of the offense charged, and discloses the circumstances of the act, or the share and participation which he had in it.’ ”

State v. Royce,

38 Wash. 111, 80 Pac. 268 (1905). The testimony noticed did not concern a confession. Consequently, we do not deal with the statutory or constitutional restrictions upon the admissibility of confessions.

Appellant claims that the evidence “failed to establish the corpus delicti in said case.” It is assumed that this claim is addressed to each of the six counts.

In arson, “the

corpus delicti

consists of two elements: (1) that the building in question burned; and (2) that it burned as the result of the willful and criminal act of some person.” Curtis, Law of Arson, 8, chapter 1, § 6;

State v. Pienick,

46 Wash. 522, 90 Pac. 645. The evidence, although circumstantial, on each count amply supports (1) that the fire was incendiary in origin, and (2) that the appellant was present on each occassion under very suspicious circumstances.

The first fire occurred February 26, 1959, in the Simpson hotel at about three o’clock in the morning, at which time the appellant was a patron in the Riviera restaurant which directly joined the hotel lobby through a doorway.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.