District Court, D. Delaware March 23, 1961, 1705 (In Re Pusey and Jones Corporation)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-03-1961
LEAHY, Senior District Judge.
1. Deemer contends that the “six-months’ rule” which had its origin in the railroad receivership cases,
1
should be and has been extended to private corporations. To support this contention, it relies upon the rule of In re Columbia Ribbon Co.,
2
reasserted by this Court in Wilmington Speedway Inc.,
3
the cases of Dudley v. Mealey
4
and Diamond State Motor Freight, Inc.,
5
6and Collier on Bankruptcy, (14 ed.) § 9.13
[5].'
6
The cited authority does not, upon analysis, provide the desired support. The rule of Columbia Ribbon Co. involves the priority of expenses incurred during the time of reorganization and has no applicability to expenses incurred prior to that time. In Dudley v. Mealey, the Court held only that provision for paying the claims for necessities furnished within six months did not automatically invalidate the plan.
7
Although favorable in its language, the case, as a proposition of law, does not support Deemer’s contention. The Matter of Diamond State Freight Inc. is also not in point. There the application of the six months’ rule in the plan was unopposed. The Court in that case did not raise this objection sua sponte since the plan had apparent creditor acceptance and was not unfair or unequitable on its face. Finally, while a portion of § 9.13 [5] of Collier is relevant,
8
an examination of the cases in its footnote reveals a lack of supporting authorities.
9
*235
The untenableness of Deem-er’s contention becomes apparent upon examination of the development of the “six-months’ rule” against the underlying policies of the bankruptcy statutes. The genesis of the “six-months’ rule” is found in decisional judge-made law because there is clearly no statutory font.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit