Court of Appeals of Texas July 11, 1961, 7297 (Magnolia Pipe Line Company v. City of Tyler)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-07-1961

FANNING, Justice.

The City of Tyler, appellee, brought suit against Magnolia Pipe Line Company, appellant, and Tomas G. Pollard for a declaratory judgment.

Magnolia, as grantee, received two pipe line, easements from fee owners in 1931, wherein rights were granted over the Thed-ford and Nichols lands to construct and operate a pipe line for the transportation of crude oil, which line was promptly and properly constructed at a proper depth. Both easements contain a clause reading in part as follows: ’

“The said grantor to fully use and enjoy the said premises, except for the purposes hereinbefore granted to said Magnolia Pipe Line Company, who hereby agrees to pay any damages which may arise to crops and fences from the laying, erecting, maintaining and operating for said pipe, telegraph and telephone lines; * * *. It is further agreed that said pipe shall be buried to a sufficient depth so as to not to interfere with cultivation of soil.”

In 1931 the lands covered by the easements were in a wooded rural area. Also at that time the pipe line easements did not pass under any land upon which there was a then existing road, highway or street. Pollard later acquired the fee title to said lands subject to said easements. He platted and subdivided the land, or a portion of it, as a residential area in 1956. In 1953 the lands were taken into the corporate limits of the City of Tyler.

The City of Tyler accepted the plat and subdivision made by Pollard, and began to maintain DeCharles, Keaton, and other streets so platted. In 1958 the City decided to pave DeCharles and Keaton Streets with a permanent type of paving and established grades for this purpose. The grade conflicted with the pipe line, and it had to be lowered or the grade for the new streets changed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.