Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit June 7, 1961, 502-58 (Citizens Federal Savings and Loan Association of Cleveland v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 07-06-1961
DURFEE, Judge.
The general question presented by this suit is whether or not a “Federal Insurance Reserve” deducted from income in previous years by a liquidated domestic building and loan association is taxable to a transferee building and loan association for the year in which it acquired all of the assets and liabilities of the liquidated association.
Prior to November 1955, the Berea Savings and Loan Company was a building and loan association operating in Ohio, as the plaintiff is at the present time. In July of that year, Berea’s stockholders voted to accept plaintiff’s offer to purchase Berea’s assets and assume its liabilities. Negotiations for the transfer were undertaken and a plan of dissolution was adopted in October. On November 1, 1955, Berea sold plaintiff all of its business and property, subject to its liabilities, for about $414,000, an amount arrived at using a basis of $450 for each share of stock outstanding. The sale price was paid into a trust account for the benefit of the stockholders and Berea abandoned its corporate authority and franchise a short time later. Mortgage loans in the face amount of $3,160,805.-56, representing amounts loaned by Berea, were transferred to plaintiff.
On its corporation income tax returns for the years 1952 through 1954 and for the portion of 1955 before it ceased operations, Berea had deducted amounts from gross income in the aggregate sum of $133,361.17. In each ease the amounts were equivalent to Berea’s net income and were credited to a “Federal Insur-anee Reserve,” (hereafter referred to as “reserve”) described in the returns as a bad debt reserve. Because of amounts credited prior to 1952, the reserve was carried on Berea’s balance sheet at $216,-715.93, as of October 31, 1955. Berea’s final tax return disclosed the sale of' the business during that year but it did not report any gain on the sale.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit