Court of Appeals of Kentucky June 2, 1961 (Sizemore v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-06-1961

PALMORE, Judge.

Alonzo Sizemore, charged with the wilful murder of Manuel Bentley, was found guilty of voluntary manslaughter and his penalty fixed at 21 years in the penitentiary. He appeals.

The tragedy occurred at the American Legion Club in the town of Fleming, in Letcher County, on the night of March 4, 1960. Trial was had in Pike County under a change of venue. Sizemore, a deputy sheriff of Letcher County, was the landlord of the premises and lived upstairs over the club. On the evening in question the decedent and his brother, Roy “Karo” Bentley, both having imbibed of alcoholic beverages over a period of several hours, began to scuffle or fight with each other in the club. Efforts to separate them were unsuccessful, and the custodian summoned Sizemore in his apartment upstairs to come down and restore order. In the course of getting the two brothers out the front door after forcibly separating them Sizemore shot Manuel Bentley in the back, and the wound proved fatal a week later. Sizemore had purposely fired one shot into the floor before the shooting of Bentley, but he claims that the fatal shot was accidental and unintended. The evidence conflicts as to whether he had placed the Bentleys under arrest.

The indictment was returned on April 18, 1960. It charged that Sizemore with malice aforethought wilfully and feloniously shot Manuel Bentley with a pistol on April 13, 1960, (sic) “from which shooting the said Manuel Bentley did later die.” Sufficiency of the indictment was attacked on the ground it did not show that death occurred within a year and a day after the shooting. Cf. Conner v. Com., 1878, 13 Bush 714, 719, 76 Ky. 714, 719; Roberson, § 281. However, where the indictment states when the wound was inflicted, is returned within a year and a day thereafter, and says the victim is dead, its necessary import is that the death occurred in the interim. Milburn v. Com., 1928, 223 Ky. 188, 3 S.W.2d 204.

Citing Lewis v. Com., 1910, 140 Ky. 652, 131 S.W.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.