New York Surrogate's Court October 24, 1961 (In re the Estate of Gerdik)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-10-1961

John D. Bennett, S.

In this contested nonjury prohate proceeding, decision has been reserved on the proponent’s motion to dismiss the objections at the close of the contestants’ case.

The first five objections relate to the execution of the propounded instrument, and to the contestants’ claim that the decedent, being illiterate, did not know the contents of the instrument offered for probate.

The decedent was a foreign-born resident of this country who, according to the petition, was not a citizen, although she had apparently resided here for many years. She spoke a foreign language, a Slavic tongue, referred to by different witnesses as Polish, Lithuanian or Ukranian, and at times she also used the English language. The propounded instrument is signed with an “X”.

Under circumstances where the decedent is illiterate, the proponent must show more than the usual factum of subscription and execution by the decedent (Matter of Regan, 206 App. Div. 403). The facts adduced establish satisfactorily such compliance by the proponent. The attorney draftsman and all the subscribing witnesses attested that the will was read to the decedent and, at the time of execution, she herself stated in English that “ she wanted everything left to John Fescura ”.

Objections numbered one through five inclusive are accordingly dismissed, it having been established that the propounded instrument was executed in the manner prescribed by section 21 of the Decedent Estate Law.

The contestants’ major assertion is that the decedent was allegedly suffering from insane delusions or hallucinations which affected the terms of the will. To substantiate these claims the contestants introduced testimony that the decedent would threaten her grandsons with bodily harm, stating that *1088she would kill them, and at different times she assaulted them with various weapons, including an axe and sticks.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.