New York Supreme Court September 27, 1961 (Beatty v. Donley)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-09-1961
Frank A. Gulotta, J.
Plaintiff moves here to strike the answer of defendant Donley because of his refusal to answer relevant questions propounded to him on an examination before trial. The codefendant, County of Nassau, purports to join in plaintiff’s motion, because of the refusal of Donley to permit the county to cross-examine him, although it has made no motion or cross motion of its own, but since Donley has attempted to answer the codefendant’s arguments as well, the court will dispose of that aspect of the case also.
*165Donley’s attorney erred in advising his client not to answer questions as to his drinking of intoxicating liquor prior to the accident, because it was, in his opinion, “ too remote Objections to the receipt of testimony upon an examination before trial, except as to form, are always reserved for the trial court. Aside from the fact that the parties had so stipulated, it is well settled by statute and decision (Civ. Prac. Act, § 305; Rules Civ. Prac., rule 129; Alvord & Alvord v. Joseph, 3 A D 2d 905).
Said attorney also advised his client not to answer the questions of the codefendant. He was on equally unsound ground there, although the question is perhaps not so well settled.
Buie 129-a of the Buies of Civil Practice, which covers the right of cross-examination in general, does not literally cover the question because on an adverse party examination it deals only with the right of cross-examination by the party’s own attorney. A codefendant, who has no cross complaint, does not fit into this category.
However, section 292 of the Civil Practice Act provides for moving for an examination upon notice to all parties “ who have appeared or answered ”.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit