District Court, District of Columbia April 25, 1961, Civ. A. No. 905-57 (Douglas Aircraft Co. v. Mueller)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-04-1961

SIRICA, District Judge.

Plaintiffs filed an action under 35 U.S. C.A. § 145 seeking a judgment from this Court entitling them to receive a patent on their application, Serial No. 316,325 of October 22,1952 entitled “Phosphonate Ester Hydraulic Fluid” for use in the hydraulic systems of aircraft operating at the low temperatures of high altitudes. A prior patent, issued to one Watson, also concerning an aircraft hydraulic fluid composition, taught that a mixture of dioctyl styrene phosphonate when combined with certain polymerized methacrylic acid esters (viscosity index-improving agents) produced the desired fluid viscosity at the desired low temperature. Plaintiff Moreton’s suggested composition contained a dibutyl phenyl phosphonate and possessed admitted novelty.

The issue at trial was whether plaintiffs’ composition, in the light of the prior Watson patent, met the statutory test of not being obvious to one having ordinary skill in the prior art. At trial, since plaintiffs were claiming unexpected results over a prior patent, it was necessary for them to show comparative tests between the application and the reference. Plaintiffs established that two isomers of the Watson patent were inoperative at the required low temperature (-40°F.). After trial, in their post-trial brief, the Patent Office urged that there was a third isomer of Watson’s dioctyl styrene phosphonate, called di-n-octyl styrene phosphonate, and that since plaintiffs had failed to test and show the inoperativeness of this third isomer, they had failed to sustain their burden of proof. Plaintiffs’ request to reopen the record to rebut this argument was denied by this Court, and judgment was entered for the defendants.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.