Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit May 14, 1962, 8530 (Carroll Taylor, Jacqueline Taylor and Michael Taylor, by Thomas H. Taylor, Their Next Friend, and Thomas H. Taylor, Individually v. Carl Anderson)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-1962

BOREMAN, Circuit Judge.

In Northumberland County, Virginia, on October 21, 1958, an automobile driven by Ethel P. Taylor collided with an automobile owned and driven by Carl Anderson of Wicomico Church, Virginia. Riding with Mrs. Taylor were four of her grandchildren, all residents of Maryland, and her husband, Herbert. Herbert Taylor and one of the grandchildren, Ronald Taylor, were killed in the accident. Thomas H. Taylor, the children’s father and also a resident of Maryland, was appointed administrator of his deceased son’s estate in Maryland. A Virginia resident (Lawrence M. Traylor) was appointed coadministrator of the estate to meet the requirements of Virginia law,

1

prior to the institution of the wrongful death action in Virginia. Such an action was filed in the District Court by the coadministrators against Carl Anderson and Ethel P. Taylor, individually, and against the latter as executrix of her deceased husband’s estate. In the same action and complaint, the three surviving children, through their father as next friend, sued for their personal injuries, and the father sued individually for medical expenses incurred and to be incurred by him for the injured children.

Paragraph one of the complaint alleged that the District Court had jurisdiction by reason of the diversity of citizenship of the parties, but defendants moved to dismiss the action on the ground that there was no jurisdiction in the federal court since a Virginia resident (the co-administrator of Ronald Taylor’s estate) was joined as a party plaintiff and defendant Anderson was also a citizen of Virginia.

2

The District Judge granted

*548

the defendants’ motion except that the court retained jurisdiction of the infants’ and father’s actions against Anderson, there being complete diversity between the opposing parties in those cases.

3

The coadministrators then filed a wrongful death action against Anderson in the Circuit Court of Northumberland County, Virginia. In that action, Mr. and Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.