Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit October 11, 1962, 17391_1 (Orin Osborn v. Boeing Airplane Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-10-1962

BROWNING, Circuit Judge.

Appellant, an employee of Boeing Airplane Company, brought this action to recover compensation for the use of an idea he had submitted for improvement of Boeing’s production methods.

1

The District Court granted Boeing’s motion for summary judgment. We reverse, finding material factual issues to be tried.

The parties had agreed to a pretrial order, which, under the heading “Admitted Facts,” described a “Suggestion System” through which Boeing solicited and paid for useful ideas. The pretrial order stated that appellant had submitted his idea to Boeing in December 1955 on a Suggestion System form containing the following printed provision: “Suggestions are submitted with the understanding that the Company shall have the right to use all those which are adopted, and the decision of the Company shall be final and conclusive as to the person entitled to a cash award and the amount of such award.” The pretrial order further recited that appellant had submitted his idea in reliance upon Boeing’s good faith in the administration of the Suggestion System and not upon an express contractual agreement or oral promise to compensate. The single “Issue of Law” set out in the pretrial order was whether appellant could recover under the doctrine of unjust enrichment or implied-in-law contract.

The District Court read these recitals as limiting appellant to a theory of recovery based legally upon the doctrine

*101

of quasi-contract and factually upon the submission of appellant’s idea to Boeing in December 1955 through the Suggestion System.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.