Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 26, 1962 (Benjamin v. State Liquor Authority)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-07-1962

lead-opinion

Per Curiam.

The facts involved are not disputed. Petitioners are operators of taverns in Johnson City and Town of Maine, 1ST. Y., respectively. Both had liquor licenses for the periods October 1, 1958 to September 30, 1959 and October 1, 1959 to September 30, 1960. In 1960 when their licenses came up for renewal the State Liquor Authority had reason to believe that violations had occurred during the Summer of 1959. Due to the fact that the Authority contends it did not become aware of this possibility until the middle of August of 1960 it proposed to renew respondents’ licenses upon stipulation that it could still institute proceedings and assess penalties for violations for which it ‘ ‘ could have or has already instituted revocation proceedings during the current license period.” Respondents agreed to this stipulation. At a hearing held in December, 1960 respondents admitted selling liquor to minors during the Summer of 1959 but claimed that section 118 of the Alcoholic Beverage Control Law precluded revocation of their licenses for violations occurring at that time. As a result of the hearing, respondents’ licenses were suspended. Respondents then brought the instant proceeding to review this determination. The court below held (1) that because the renewal stipulations were not introduced at the hearing they could not properly have been considered by the hearing officer and (2) that section 118 constituted a Statute of Limitations which precluded suspension for the violations in question. It is from this holding that the present appeal is brought.

The Authority urges that Special Term erred in holding that the renewal stipulations were not before the Authority at the hearing. We agree. While admittedly the stipulations were not formally received into evidence, it is - not disputed that the licenses themselves were before the Authority.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.