City of New York Municipal Court March 8, 1962 (Sol Tammy Co. v. Cohen)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-03-1962

J. Daniel Fink, J.

The plaintiff moves for summary judgment in this action commenced by it to recover the sum of $3,060.85, the reasonable value of merchandise, consisting of 149 garments which were delivered by the plaintiff to the defendants, who are common carriers, for transportation to a designated consignee. The merchandise was lost, apparently as the result of the theft of defendants’ truck.

At the time defendants’ driver received the merchandise, he signed an original and duplicate receipt in a book of receipts in the possession of the plaintiff, the receipt in question having been prepared by the plaintiff. It appears that the defendants had been making deliveries for plaintiff for a period of over five years, and had supplied the plaintiff with similar printed receipt books during that time. It was the practice to remove the original receipt from the book, to be returned later by the defendants’ driver with proof of delivery to the consignee.

The following legend appears at the bottom of these receipt forms: “note — ‘In consideration of the rate charged, the shipper agrees that the company shall not be liable for more than $50.00 on any shipment accepted for delivery to one consignee, unless a greater value is declared at the time of shipment, and charge for such greater value paid or agreed to be paid. Where a greater value is declared the charge will be based at 10^5 for each $100.00 of declared value. ’ ”

It is obvious that the merchandise having been stolen the defendants are liable in some amount for the nondelivery of the shipment; the plaintiff contending that the defendants are liable for the full value of the merchandise shipped, while the defendants insist that the agreed valuation of $50 is the utmost which the plaintiff may lawfully claim.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.