New York Supreme Court April 24, 1962 (Groeber v. New York City Transit Authority)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-04-1962
Matthew M. Levy, J.
This is a motion by the plaintiff to amend her notice of claim and the complaint to increase the damages demanded.
The accident occurred in March, 1960. The complaint was served in April, 1961. While the plaintiff seems to me to have been aware of the extent of her injuries prior to the service of her complaint, the defendant has not, in my opinion, been prejudiced by the plaintiff’s failure to anticipate the damages she would likely suffer.
The defendant relies upon the case of Natale v. Pepsi-Cola Co. (7 A D 2d 282) wherein the Appellate Division held that, where “ the increase in the ad damnum clause is sought during trial, it should appear that the * * * amount demanded is consonant with the proof of damages and not excessive, otherwise it cannot be said to be without prejudice to the defendant ’ ’ (p. 285). But, in a related case (not cited by the defendant), Natale v. Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. (8 A D 2d 781) I find that where the motion was made before and not at the trial, the Appellate Division — holding that it was within the judicial discretion of Special Term to grant the motion — said: “ The amendment granted does not change the issues and, in our opinion, in no wise is indicative of the merits of the case. We give no more weight to the increased amount than we would have given had it been asserted originally. That is, an ad damnum clause merely informs an adversary of the maximum amount of the claim asserted without in any wise being proof of injury or indeed of liability.” At this point it is quite pertinent to note that the present cause has not yet been noticed for trial.
Although the defendant opposes the motion on the ground that the plaintiff has not submitted corroborative medical proof to substantiate causal connection to warrant the increased damages, the hospital and physicians’ prior records and reports *971adequately demonstrate that the plaintiff’s damages may be substantially greater than originally claimed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit