Appellate Court of Illinois December 4, 1962, Gen. No. 48,750 (Sphatt v. Tulley)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1962

MR. PRESIDING JUSTICE BRYANT

delivered the opinion of the court:

This is an appeal from a judgment in the amount of $110,000 in favor of the plaintiff for injuries sustained by him as the result of an automobile accident which occurred on the North Tri-State Tollway on August 11, 1960. On that night plaintiff, with his wife and ‘two daughters, was driving in a northerly direction in his 1941 Plymouth automobile with a two-wheel trailer attached. Shortly after passing the O’Hare Oasis, plaintiff stopped at the side of the road to check the trailer hitch and the taillights and to determine why the trailer had been riding “bumpy” for a number of miles. While he was standing between the trailer and the rear bumper of his car, checking the trailer hitch, the defendants’ car collided with the rear of the plaintiff’s trailer and the resulting impact crushed the plaintiff between the trailer and the car. He suffered fractured ribs, a cranial injury, multiple lacerations, a partial collapse of one lung, and multiple fractures of both legs which resulted in the surgical amputation of his right leg.

At the time of the collision the defendants were entering the Tollway from the Oasis where they had stopped to purchase gasoline and refreshments. The evidence is conflicting as to whether the plaintiff parked in the emergency lane of the Tollway or if he had stopped his vehicles wholly or in part on the lane used for entering the Tollway from the Oasis. The jury resolved that question of fact in favor of the plaintiff and rendered the verdict from which the present judgment is appealed.

In urging us to reverse the judgment of the Superior Court, the defendant has alleged that the trial court committed eight distinct reversible errors, each of which will be considered in the succeeding paragraphs of this opinion.

The defendants first maintain that plaintiff’s instruction No. 17 should not have been submitted to the jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.