District Court, W.D. Virginia January 9, 1962, Civ. A. No. 607 (Frazier v. Beard)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-01-1962
DALTON, Chief Judge.
This suit for damages, based upon personal injuries sustained as a result of a collision between two automobiles, was tried before the Court and jury. The jury on December 15,1961, found in favor of the plaintiff and assessed his damages at $5,000.00. Defendant has moved that the verdict of the jury be set aside and that a new trial be granted.
The defendant submits four grounds to support the motion:
(1) The verdict was excessive and appeared to have been given under the influence of passion and prejudice;
(2) The evidence was insufficient to support the amount of the verdict;
(3) Misconduct of the jury in considering, discussing and having brought to its attention portions of a pamphlet or booklet entitled “Questions and Answers on the Motor Vehicle Code of Virginia” showing average stopping distances of automobiles traveling at different rate of speed; and
(4) The verdict was contrary to the law and the evidence.
Use of Extraneous Pamphlet by Jury
First, as to ground number (3) of the defendant’s motion to set aside the verdict and to grant a new trial alleging misconduct of the jury in considering information taken from a pamphlet or booklet prepared by the Division of Motor Vehicles, additional facts must be noted in order that proper understanding can be had on the discussion that follows.
It seems that during a recess of this Court on December 15, 1961, before deliberations had begun, a member of the jury obtained from a Virginia state trooper a pamphlet or booklet entitled “Questions and Answers on the Motor Vehicle Code of Virginia”, published and distributed by the State Division of Motor Vehicles. The juror .took this pamphlet with him to the jury room and there brought to the attention of the other jurors and discussed with them the contents of this pamphlet, particularly a table entitled “Average Stopping Distance” showing the average stopping distances of vehicles at varying rates of speed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit