District Court, E.D. New York February 21, 1962, No. 61-CD-693 (United States v. 284,392 Square Feet of Floor Space)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-1962

BARTELS, District Judge.

In this condemnation proceeding a motion is made by the Government to dispense with the taking of an oral deposition of such officers or agents of the Government “as may have knowledge of the value of the property” involved herein. The notice also calls for the production of appraisal reports and documents relating to value in the Government’s possession.

Both sides raise the question as to whether the books and records can be ordered on such an examination without compliance with Rule 34, F.R.Civ.P. 28 U.S.C.A. and whether the appraisals are cloaked with the protection of Hickman v. Taylor, 1947, 329 U.S. 495, 67 S.Ct. 385, 91 L.Ed. 451. There has been no showing that would invoke the protection of the “work product rule”, nor has there been any reason advanced to excuse the application of Rule 34 with respect to the books and records. Defendants cannot seriously contend that they can circumvent the “good cause” requirement of Rule 34 by noticing an oral deposition. *77Moreover, if books and records are sought to assist the witness in testifying, the record does not disclose that a subpoena duces tecum was served.

The crux of this application is simply whether the opinions of the experts in the Government’s employ, on the issue of value as contained in appraisals in the Government’s possession, are discoverable.

Defendants rely on United States v. 50.34 Acres of Land, etc., D.C.N.Y., 1952, 13 F.R.D. 19, and United States v. Certain Parcels of Land, etc., D.C.Cal., 1954, 15 F.R.D. 224, as well as other cases which are not condemnation cases and which need not be considered. Both of the above cases are Rule 34 cases, but are not controlling for more important reasons. Insofar as United States v. 50.34 Acres permitted discovery of opinions contained in appraisals, this Court does not believe it is in accordance with the most accepted authorities, and inasmuch as United States v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.