District Court, E.D. Tennessee April 2, 1962, No. 3388 (Byrd v. Belcher)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-04-1962

C. G. NEESE, District Judge.

Ora Byrd (Frisbee) brings this action as the surviving widow of Carl Byrd for her said decedent’s alleged wrongful death by drowning on Chickamauga Lake on December 23, 1957. The tragic accident occurred at about 5:00 o’clock, p. m., in the vicinity of Harrison Bay Boat Dock in Hamilton County, Tennessee, allegedly resulting proximately from the negligent operation of a boat by the respondent, C. W. Belcher.

While the testimony offered on behalf of the libelant was burdened with numer*646ous and often glaring inconsistencies and contradictions, the Court finds that the following is a reasonably accurate account of the facts established:

The libelant’s decedent, the libelant herself, and Mr. and Mrs. Charles W. Alvis, sister and brother-in-law of the libelant, were passengers in a boat being operated by the decedent Byrd. The two women were riding on the center seat of the Byrd boat, Alvis was positioned in the bow of the boat, while the decedent was in the stern of the boat and operating the outboard motor.

Byrd and Alvis had put the decedent’s boat in the water a short time before the accident occurred. Byrd’s boat was a 14-foot aluminum craft powered with a 10- or 12-horsepower outboard motor. After a brief sally out into the Harrison Bay area, the men returned to shore and were joined in the craft by their respective wives; whereupon it was decided that the party would visit the Harrison Bay Dock area and view the larger craft lying at anchor there.

Thus, about one and a half hours after arriving at the lakeside, the Byrds and Alvises were navigating near the entrance to the boat dock area a short distance from the shore and at a speed estimated at ten to fifteen miles per hour when the boat in which they were riding capsized, apparently swamped by waves. All four occupants of the craft were thrown into the water and the libelant’s decedent, Carl Byrd, was drowned.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.