District Court, E.D. Pennsylvania March 19, 1962, Libel No. 18 of 1959 (United States v. Two Lots of Ground & Improvements Thereon Located on Spruce Street)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-03-1962

VAN DUSEN, District Judge.

This action, which was brought under 26 U.S.C.A. § 5606,1 is a libel to forfeit real estate alleged to have been used for the operation of an unlicensed still. An answer to the libel was filed by Abe Markowitz, President of the David Realty Corporation (Document No. 8). The answer denied any knowledge on the part of the corporation of the illegal use to which the property here involved was put.2 After a motion for partial summary judgment filed by the Government (Document No. 9) had been denied,3 the respondents filed a motion to dismiss this libel. The motion was based on a plea of res judicata, the respondents arguing that an acquittal of Abe Markowitz in a criminal prosecution barred the Government from re-litigating in the present civil action the same issue and claim as had been advanced in the former criminal action.4 This motion was argued before Judge Grim, who denied the motion to dismiss on June 1, 1961 (Document No. 18), stating in part:

“The answer clearly sets up a claim to the accused real estate on behalf of the corporation but does not aver any facts establishing a claim on behalf of Markowitz. Since Markowitz was the person acquitted and on the face of the answer it *7appears that the claim is in fact that of a corporation, there is no identity between the acquitted defendant and the real claimant, and the acquittal is no bar to the proceeding.” 5

After a pre-trial conference was held, respondents filed a motion for leave to amend the answer previously filed on behalf of David Realty Corporation. The proposed amended answer incorporates the previous answer and asserts as an affirmative defense a claim on behalf of Abe Markowitz, as an individual and sole shareholder of the David Realty Corporation.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.