California Supreme Court May 14, 1963, Crim. 7156 (People v. Lichens)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-1963

McCOMB, J.

Prom a judgment of guilty of assault by means of force and violence likely to produce great bodily injury, predicated upon defendant’s plea of guilty, he appeals. ,

Defendant applied for probation, and the matter was referred to the probation ■ officer, who made a report recommending probation. The trial court denied probation and sentenced defendant.

Defendant contends that the trial court, in considering probation, listened to, and was influenced by, hearsay evidence not contained in the probation officer’s report and not presented at a judicial hearing.

This contention is devoid of merit. At the time defendant was sentenced the trial judge said: “I’m regarding him [defendant] as being eligible for probation and I’m denying probation and at this time I am preparing to sentence him, unless you have .something further to say for the record.”

It is further clear from the trial court’s statements that matters outside the record did not serve as the basis for the order denying probation.

Trial judges often read newspapers, hear radio reports, or even overhear conversations or receive unwelcome letters containing statements relative to a case they are hearing; but if they are qualified for théir office, they disregard all such statements insofar as evidentiary consideration is concerned.

The trial judge is as capable of disregarding these facts as he is of disregarding irrelevant evidence to which he has sustained objections, or has struck from the record, in a trial to the court without a jury.

The colloquy between the court and counsel demonstrates that probation was denied on the merits after .the court’s consideration of the probation officer’s report and the record of the preliminary examination. Under such circumstances,

*589

no abuse of discretion is made to appear in its denial of the probation report.

In

People

v.

Lopez,

151 Cal.App.2d 121 [311 P.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.