Court of Criminal Appeals of Oklahoma December 4, 1963, A-13395 (Antuna v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1963

NIX, Judge.

Joe Nova Antuna, plaintiff in error, hereinafter referred to as the defendant, was charged in the District Court of Johnston County with the crime of Robbery in the First Degree. He appeared before the District Judge on March IS, 1963, accompanied by his attorney, and withdrew his plea of Not Guilty, entered a plea of Guilty to the reduced charge of Robbery in the Second Degree, and was sentenced to a term of two years in the State Penitentiary. From this judgment and sentence he now attempts to appeal.

The defendant asserts that he was coerced into entering the plea of Guilty, as he had previously worked out arrangements with the county attorney whereby he would recommend a suspended sentence.

After hearing defense counsel ask for leniency, and the county attorney recommend a suspended sentence

if

restitution would be made to the robbery victim, and due to the fact that defendant had been in no serious trouble; the trial judge, however, sentenced him to two years. Then counsel attempted to withdraw the plea of guilty, and same was denied by the court, thus defendant’s main contention that this constituted an abuse of discretion.

After a careful examination of the record before us, it is apparent that

no

promises were made to defendant by the trial judge. The county attorney agreed to recommend a suspended sentence, which he did, not only in this case but in the companion case (State v. Bearden) which was heard just preceding this. The judge did' not suspend the sentence in that case, yet defense counsel elected to plead Mr. Antuna guilty, on the supposition that he would receive a suspended sentence, and then expressed surprise when he did not. It seems-highly improbable that the court’s actions could have been so prejudicial in one case and yet counsel would nevertheless proceed to follow the same course in the other. Defendant gambled and lost on his bet that the judge would suspend the sentence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.