Supreme Court of Oklahoma September 17, 1963, 39816 (Braine v. City of Stroud)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-09-1963
WELCH, Justice.
Plaintiffs in error have appealed from the judgment of the trial court sustaining a demurrer to their petition for damages. The action on appeal was instituted May 9, 1961. Plaintiff had-on October 7, 1960, in a sepa•rate case, obtained judgment in a mandamus proceeding against the defendants and ■a copy of that judgment was attached to the petition in this cause. The petition showed that in the mandamus proceeding 'the trial court had directed the reconnection of electric, water and sewer services at plaintiffs’ residence, enjoined the city ■ from attempting to' collect the garbage bill for the period during which service was
*430
suspended, directed that the city pick up refuse including vines and grass when placed in containers in consideration of plaintiffs’ resumption of payments of garbage fees, and that the city should pay the costs of the mandamus proceedings. The petition in the cause now before us alleges that the plaintiffs were in the former cause damaged by being required to employ an attorney, suffered other financial loss in that a large supply of foods and meats in their deep freeze and refrigerator was lost, and that they and two grandchildren who were their guests, were forced to abandon their residence and stay at a motel during the time the City discontinued electric, water and sewer service. The demurrer to the petition which the trial court sustained, in addition to the ground of failure in stating a cause of action, set forth that if damages were recoverable by plaintiffs the same could only be recovered in the prior case, and not in a separate action.
A general rule is stated in 1 A.L.R. p. 1693 to the effect that an injured person may have his choice between an action for damages and a remedy by mandamus, but that he cannot pursue both remedies unless both are given by statute.
In this State the remedy by mandamus is authorized and governed by statutory provisions, namely, 12 O.S.1961, §§ 1451-1462 inclusive.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit