Supreme Court of Colorado April 15, 1963, 20112 (Daigle v. Prather)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1963

Mr. Justice McWilliams

delivered the opinion of the Court.

In his complaint Harry Daigle, plaintiff in the trial court, alleged that he suffered damages in the amount of $15,000 as the direct result of negligence on the part of the defendant, Dorothy Prather. In her answer Prather denied that she was in any wise negligent and affirmatively alleged that the automobile collision, out of which the litigation stems, resulted from the sudden failure of her brakes and was an unavoidable accident.

The evidence adduced upon trial disclosed that at about one o’clock P.M. on November 8, 1960, Daigle, who had been proceeding in a westerly direction on East 32nd Avenue approaching Monaco, in Denver, had stopped his motor vehicle for a traffic control signal light, which as of that moment was “red.” While in this “stopped” position awaiting the change of the signal light to green, his car was struck in the rear by a vehicle then being driven by Prather. Prather was also traveling in a westerly direction on East 32nd Avenue near Monaco, and she testified that when she was “at least three or four car lengths” behind the Daigle vehicle she observed that the signal light was red and that his car was stopped therefor. She further stated her speed at the time “couldn’t have been more than thirty miles an hour,” and she later modified this by stating that she thought her speed “was around between twenty and thirty.” While preparing to make what she declared was to be a “normal” stop, she stepped on the brake pedal which went “clear to the floor” and she thereafter crashed into the rear end of the Daigle vehicle because of this brake failure. In response to a series of

*117

specific questions as to why she didn’t use the emergency brake, or “cut to the right” or “cut to the left,” Mrs. Prather in each instance said “it was too sudden.”

A police officer testified that he arrived at the scene of the accident shortly after its occurrence and that Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.