Supreme Court of North Carolina October 30, 1963, 172 (Harrison v. Williams)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-10-1963

Bobbitt, J.

The only question is whether the court erred ,in granting defendant’s motion for judgment ¡of involuntary nonsuit. Decision depends upon whether the evidence, when ¡considered in the light most favorable to plaintiff, is sufficient to support a finding that plaintiff’s fall and injuries were proximately ¡caused by the negligence of defendant.

It is unnecessary to restate the familiar and well .settled general legal principles pertinent to decision on this appeal. This has been ¡done in numerous oases including the following:

Reese v. Piedmont, Inc.,

240 N.C. 391, 82 S.E. 2d 365;

Sledge v. Wagoner,

248 N.C. 631, 104 S.E. 2d 195;

Skipper v. Cheatham,

249 N.C. 706, 107 S.E. 2d 625;

Garner v. Greyhound Corp.,

250 N.C. 151, 108 S.E. 2d 461, 81 A.L.R. 2d 741.

*395

Defendant contends pl-aintiff fell in a portion of his premises not designed for .use by patrons and was not an invitee with reference to the place where she fell. However, there was evidence that patrons of the dining rooms frequently went into, the kitchen area of the premises to pay /their bills. Too, there was evidence that plaintiff, having obtained change for the express purpose of buying cigarettes, was proceeding as directed by defendant’s employee.

Cupita v. Country Club,

252 N.C. 346, 113 S.E. 2d 712, cited by defendant, is readily distinguishable. In our view, there was sufficient evidence to support a jury finding that plaintiff was an invitee at the time and place of her fall and injury.

Defendant owed plaintiff, as invitee, the legal duty to maintain the aisles and passageways of its place of business in such condition as a reasonably careful and prudent proprietor would deem sufficient to protect patrons from danger while exercising ordinary care for their own safety.

Skipper v. Cheatham, supra; Sledge v. Wagoner,

250 N.C. 559, 109 S.E. 2d 180.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.