Supreme Court of Virginia January 14, 1963, Record 5522 (Spiegelman v. Birch)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-1963

Buchanan, J.,

delivered the opinion of the court.

Joshua W. Birch, seventy-three years old, was struck and killed by an automobile driven by Robert Spiegelman, seventeen years old. His administrator brought this action for damages against Spiegelman, who defended by his guardian

ad litem.

A jury returned a verdict of $10,000 for the plaintiff, upon which the court entered judgment and we granted the defendant a writ of error.

Defendant’s first contention here is that the court erred in overruling his motion to dismiss the plaintiff’s action for lack of legal service of process. The sheriff certified that on October 20, 1960, he served a copy of the motion for judgment on defendant by posting it at the front door of defendant’s usual place of abode, neither he nor any member of his family over sixteen years of age being then found there. This was in accord with § 8-51 of the Code, but the defendant based his motion on an affidavit of his father to the effect that about September 5, 1960, he and his wife and their son, the defendant, went to Florida “and our permanent home at Chincoteague, Accomack County, Virginia, was unoccupied from that date, up to November 5, 1960”. It sufficiently appears that the defendant was only temporarily absent from the home which was his usual place of abode and his motion to dismiss was properly overruled. Burks PI. & Pr., 4 ed., p. 75; Black’s Law Diet., 3 ed., p. 12.

Cf.

Code § 8-53.

Defendant’s next contention is that the court erred in overruling his motion to strike the plaintiff’s evidence at its conclusion because it did not show that defendant was guilty of any negligence. He waived his right to rely on that motion by introducing his own evidence and the entire record is now to be considered.

Interstate Veneer Co.

v.

Edwards,

191 Va. 107, 110, 60 S. E. 2d 4, 6;

Carroll

v.

Richardson,

201 Va. 157, 158, 110 S. E. 2d 193, 194.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.