Supreme Court of Georgia October 15, 1963, 22186 (Riley v. Garrett)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-10-1963

Mobley, Justice.

The writ of error presents the question of whether or not the crime of sodomy as defined by the laws of Georgia includes the unnatural copulation between a man and a woman per linguam in vagina.

“Sodomy is the carnal knowledge and connection against the order of nature, by man with man, or in the same unnatural manner with woman.”

Code

§ 26-5901. In

Herring v. State,

119 Ga. 709 (2) (46 SE 876), this court held that sodomy can be committed by two men per os, as well as per anum, since the statutory definition "contains no limitation as to the organ with which such unnatural connection may be made.” Though the

Herring

case was not decided by a full bench, one justice having been absent, in

White v. State,

136 Ga. 158 71 SE 135), a full bench approved and followed the

Herring

case doctrine that sodomy as defined by the laws of Georgia may be committed by two men per os as well as per anum. The full bench decision of

Thompson v. Aldredge,

187 Ga. 467 (200 SE 799), did not hold that the unnatural act of copulation per linguam in vagina is not sodomy under the laws of Georgia; rather, the decision simply followed the statutory definition of sodomy which excludes the possibility of the commission of the crime by two women, though the crime may be accomplished by two men or by a man and a woman. Nevertheless, the latter decision should have been taken as portending a judgment of this court construing

Code

§ 26-5901 as not proscribing

any

connection per

*347

linguam in vagina since there is no apparent reason why the legislature would have intended to punish a man and a woman for doing the same act which would not be punishable if done by two women.

We have not found a decision of this court which is squarely on point with the facts of the case sub judice. However, the case of

Comer v. State,

21 Ga. App. 306 (94 SE 314), involved precisely the facts here involved.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.