District Court, District of Columbia July 25, 1963, Civ. A. 2096-61 (Phillips Petroleum Company v. Ladd)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-07-1963

JACKSON, District Judge.

This is an action brought pursuant to 35 U.S.C. § 145, praying this Court to adjudge that plaintiff is entitled to receive a patent defined by two claims which were rejected by the Board of Appeals of the United States Patent Office.

The applicants are David R. Smith, and Robert P. Zelinski, employees of plaintiff at the time of their invention. The application, Serial No. 578,166, filed April 16, 1956, entitled “Process and Catalyst for Production of Rubbery Polymers” was assigned to plaintiff.

All of the 15 process claims were allowed, and the issue here relates to product claims 17 and 19, reading as follows:

“17. A rubbery polymer of 1,3-butadiene characterized by at least 85 per cent

cis

1,4-addition.”

“19. A rubbery polymer of 1,3-butadiene in which the polymer is formed and characterized by cis 1,4-addition, trans 1,4-addition and 1,2-addition of the butadiene, at least 85 per cent of the polymer being formed and characterized by cis 1,4-addi-tion.”

The primary Examiner rejected the involved claims over either of the Greene or Binder references, and also as unduly broad in that it disclosed as a minimum at least 85% cis 1,4.

The Board of Appeals in its decision affirmed the rejections of the Examiner. However, it did not sustain the objection on the breadth of the claims for the reason that, in its opinion, the disclosure amply supported the claim for cis 1,4 additions above 85% as a critical low element.

The references relied upon are as follows:

Greene Patent No. 2,762,790 Dated: September 11,1956 Application dated: December 26, 1952

An article by John L. Binder Entitled: “Microstructures of Polybutadienes and. Butadiene-Styrene Copolymers”

Vol. No. 46 — Industrial and Engineering Chemistry

Pages — 1727-1730 (August 1954)

The Greene patent, all claims of which are for process, is entitled “Polymerization of Aliphatic Conjugated Diolefins”.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.