District Court, D. South Dakota April 16, 1963, Civ. 1314 (Fishback v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-04-1963
MICKELSON, Chief Judge.
Plaintiffs in this action, Horace Fish-back, Jr., and Margaret N. Fishback, husband and wife, bring this action to recover the additional income taxes assessed and paid by them in the amount of $3,489.56, plus interest, as a result of the disallowing of capital gains treatment on income received from the sale of certain property in the years 1956, 1957 and 1958. Plaintiff Margaret N. Fishback is a necessary party only because she signed joint tax returns for the years in question. Hereinafter, reference will be made only to Mr. Fish-back, as “taxpayer”, unless otherwise noted.
Taxpayer is a long time resident of Brookings, South Dakota. He has been engaged in the banking business in Brookings since 1925, and is presentir president of the First National Bank in that city.
Taxpayer’s father, Horace Fishback,. Sr., acquired the land in question, a 20-acre tract on the north edge of Brook-ings, in 1898. Upon his death in- 1929';. the land became a part of his estate and descended to members of his family. In 1946, taxpayer acquired title to the-tract when an adjustment of family property interests was made. There was no-cash transaction and taxpayer took the land at the inventory price of $4,000. Prior to 1946, the land had been used for pasturing livestock and was commonly referred to in the community as “Fish-back’s pasture.” Taxpayer testified that, he intended to continue to use the property for pasture purposes at the time he-acquired it in 1946, and the evidence-shows that he did so use it subsequent to that time. The land was unplatted and unimproved. In 1950 or 1951, a sewer line and curb and gutter were installed on Sixth Avenue, the street which bounds the property on the east. Taxpayer’s share of the cost was $1,497.23.
Taxpayer was approached in 1950 and 1951 about selling lots in the tract. He testified, however, that he was not interested in doing so. Taxpayer was not engaged in the real estate business as such.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit