Court of Appeals of Texas May 29, 1963, 11103 (Railroad Commission v. Shell Oil Company)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-1963

PHILLIPS, Justice.

This is an appeal by the Railroad Commission and certain intervenors from the judgment of the district court cancelling an allocation formula contained in the field rules

1

promulgated by the Commission for four oil fields in Wood County, Texas, namely, the Southeast Quitman (Kirkland), the Southeast Quitman (Rodessa), the Southeast Quitman Goldsmith (Kirkland) and the Southeast Quitman Goldsmith (Ro-dessa) fields. The appellees, plaintiffs below, are Shell Oil Company, Amerada Petroleum Corporation and Sun Oil Company.

: Appellees brought suit under Section 8 of Article 6049c, Vernon’s Texas Civil Statutes, alleging that the allocation of al-lowables among the wells set out in Rule 3

2

of the abovementioned field rules prorating the wells in each of the four fields in question on a 50%' per well 50% acreage basis fails to protect the correlative rights of the parties, that the formula causes uncompensated drainage from the appellees’ leases and deprives the appellees and their royalty owners from the reasonable opportunity of producing their fair share of oil from the reservoirs and further deprives them of their property without due process of law. Appellees further allege that there is no substantial evidence to sustain the 50-50 allocation formula. In addition to declaring the allocation formula null and void, the appellees asked that the court grant them an injunction permanently enjoining the Commission from applying the 50-50 for allocation formula to the fields in question.

*365

The trial court found that Rule Number 3 of the abovementioned field rules was not reasonably supported by substantial evidence, was arbitrary, unreasonable, capricious and confiscatory, that it was null and void and permanently enjoined the Commission from enforcing the allocation formula.

The intervenors are C. A. Green and R. J. McMurrey. These intervenors aligned themselves with the position taken by the Railroad Commission. C. A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.