North Dakota Supreme Court October 9, 1963, 8098 (Frank v. Schaff)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-10-1963

STRUTZ, Judge.

This is an action for damages for conversion of personal property. The plaintiff and the defendants were the owners of a section of land in Grant County, the plaintiff having title to two quarters and the defendants owning the other two quarters in.the section. The parties discussed the matter of installing a line fence between their properties, and in furtherance of this idea the plaintiff and the defendant William Schaff attempted to determine the party line between their properties where such fence would be erected. After attempting to locate such party line, the defendant William Schaff felt that they had not been able to properly locate the dividing line and he decided to hire a surveyor to establish such line. There is evidence in the record that he informed the plaintiff that he was not satisfied with their joint attempts to locate the party line and that he was going to hire a surveyor to determine it. Before the defendant was able to have the property surveyed, however, the plaintiff erected a fence at his own expense, placing the fence on the line which the parties had tentatively determined to be the border between their properties. Admittedly, a portion of the fence erected by the plaintiff was on the defendants’ land. After the surveyor retained by the defendant William Schaff had determined the correct property line, the defendant informed the plaintiff that he would have to move and relocate the fence and place it either on the plaintiff’s land or on the property line.

At the time the defendant made his demand, he told the plaintiff that there was no

*829

particular hurry about moving the fence, but that it should be done without too much delay. In the defendant’s own words,

“ * * * I told him he don’t have to move the fence today, but he’s got to move it sometime in the near future. He says he was making hay.”

The plaintiff never did get around to moving his fence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.