Michigan Supreme Court September 4, 1963, Calendar 12, 13, Docket 49,752, 49,753 (Smith v. Village of Wood Creek Farms)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-09-1963
Dethmers, J.
Plaintiffs are owners of outlots A. and B of Supervisor’s Plat of Wood Creek Farms’
*129
¿nd outlots C and D of Supervisor’s Plat of Wood Creek Farms No. 1 in defendant village. They seek, in 2 cases, one as to outlot A and the other as to outlots B, C, and D, to enjoin enforcement as to those outlots of a zoning ordinance classifying the lots as “Residence No. 1”, which is the classification of the entire square mile composing the village. Defendants filed cross-bills seeking to enjoin plaintiffs from advertising and maintaining signs, on the lots indicating that they are zoned “restricted commercial”. The 2 cases were combined for trial and appeal. From decree granting plaintiffs the relief they sought as to outlots A, B, and C, but denying it as to outlot D, and denying defendants the relief sought in their cross-bills as to outlots A, B, and C, but granting it as to outlot D, defendants appealed and plaintiffs cross-appealed as to outlot D only.
The trial court found that outlots A, B, and C were “grossly undesirable and unfit for residential purposes”, but that this was not true of outlot D. That presents the crucial question here on appeal. Defendants raise 7 questions concerning admissibility of evidence, which we need not determine because we hear the case
de novo
and decide, without consideration of the evidence to which defendants object, that the trial court made proper disposition of the cases.
Bruso
v.
Pinquet,
321 Mich 630, 640.
All 4 of the outlots border on Northwestern highway, which bisects the village from its northwestern to its southeastern corners and separates the 2 mentioned supervisor’s plats. It is a very heavily traveled, high-speed, 4-lane superhighway.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit