Supreme Court of Iowa March 12, 1963, 50876 (French v. Universal CIT Credit Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-03-1963

Thornton, J.

— Plaintiff seeks to replevin an automobile repossessed from him by defendants. Plaintiff’s claim is that he purchased the 1958 Buick Limited from defendant Dickey Ford Sales, Inc., on March 28, 1959, a conditional sales contract was made out but later he paid for the car in full and the conditional sales contract was to be mailed to him. He did receive a certificate of title showing no lien. Defendant Dickey Ford contends plaintiff bought the car and entered into the conditional sales contract but at no time paid the price and that the failure of the certificate of title to show the lien of the conditional sale was due to a mistake and inadvertence on its part. Universal C. I. T. claims as a purchaser of the conditional sales contract from Dickey Ford and that its repossession was right because plaintiff had not made the payments as provided in the contract.

The jury believed the plaintiff’s story and awarded him judgment, fixing the value of the car on the date of the taking at $3000, and for damages for wrongful detention in the sum of $1000. Defendants appeal urging numerous errors for reversal.

This is the second trial of this ease in the district court. Both

*1047

verdicts were in favor of plaintiff. The record does not show the reason for granting the second trial.

T. Defendants first contend it was error to admit in evidence plaintiff’s bank account showing he had $10,000 on deposit in July of 1956. The claim is that it was too remote and not connected up. Actually it was connected up.

It is a fair inference from plaintiff’s testimony that he withdrew the money from the bank, purchased United States Savings Bonds with part of it, later cashed the bonds and kept as much as $3500 in cash in his desk at home, and later transferred such cash to a raincoat placed in the trunk of his 1956 ear. From this source he says he took the money to pay Dickey Ford $2350 for the 1958 Buick on March 28, 1959. He simply traced the source of his funds.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.