Supreme Court of Iowa March 12, 1963, 50809 (Mundy v. Olds)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-03-1963
Snell, J.
— This is the second appeal involving the same highway accident. See Mundy v. Olds, 252 Iowa 888, 109 N.W. 2d 241.
At about 7 p.m. February 1, 1959, plaintiff, accompanied by his wife and infant child, was driving* north on Highway No. 14 just south of Knoxville. The paving* was 20 feet wide with shoulders 8 to 10 feet wide. The weather was cold and the highway icy. Snow had been pushed by the highway maintenance crew to the shoulder of the road on plaintiff’s right forming a snowbank. Plaintiff’s car ran out of gas. His car was on the east or right-hand side of the highway. Plaintiff and his wife testified that his car was against the snowbank and as far to the right as possible and completely off the pavement. Defendant and a deputy sheriff investigating the accident testified that the car was one third to one half of its width on the pavement.
Plaintiff saw the lights of a vehicle approaching from the south or rear. The lights were from defendant’s car. When defendant’s car was about one-half mile away plaintiff alighted from his car hoping to get help from the approaching motorist. There is a dispute in the evidence as to whether he was standing on or off the pavement. Plaintiff says he was off the pavement. Plaintiff’s testimony as to what he did is summarized (with conclusions added) by his counsel in these words:
“When defendant’s vehicle was approximately one-half block distance from the plaintiff’s vehicle, the plaintiff determined that the defendant would likely not change its course of travel thus creating a hazard to plaintiff. In a confused state of mind caused by all of the attending circumstances and conditions then existing, plaintiff pressed himself up against his
*1098
own automobile with his face away from the traveled portion of the highway. The next thing plaintiff recalled was awakening in the hospital on the following day.”
The words just quoted are the conclusions of counsel and embellish but do not misquote the record.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit