Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court June 20, 1963 (Commonwealth v. Massachusetts Turnpike Authority)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-06-1963

Wilkins, C.J.

This bill of complaint, which “represents” that it is brought by the Commonwealth, “acting by and through its Metropolitan District Commission,” prays that certain takings by the defendant Massachusetts Turnpike Authority “be declared illegal and of no force or effect,” and that the Authority “be restrained from entering upon the lands of the petitioner [sic] or in any way interfering with the operation of the water and sewer systems and the other duties of the petitioner [sic] in the control of flood conditions in the Charles River” and “from entering upon or taking possession of that portion of a reservation road known as Soldiers Field Road.” An interlocutory decree was entered overruling the Authority’s demurrer to the bill, and the case is here upon a report by the single justice of the correctness of that ruling. G. L. c. 214, § 30.

The bill first makes allegations as to the powers and duties of the commission in the construction, maintenance, and operation of sewer and water systems and a park system with roadways and boulevards; in maintaining gates and locks and the Charles River Flood Gates; in constructing, maintaining, and operating a new dam at the location of the abandoned Warren Avenue Bridge in Boston; and in the exclusive care and control of the Charles River Basin (see St. 1909, c. 524, § 2). Then follow these allegations. The Authority, acting under St. 1952, c. 354, and St. 1958, c. 384, purported to take, by orders of taking recorded in the Suffolk registry of deeds, the fee in the following land in Boston belonging to the Commonwealth and under the control of the commission: (1) approximately eight acres in the Charles River; (2) approximately eight acres in the Charles River Reservation, including a

*252

roadway known as Soldiers Field Road; and (3) 20,098 square feet in which a shaft for fresh water supply descends to a tunnel approximately 300 feet below the surface ; all, it would seem, in the Charles River Basin.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.