New Jersey Superior Court Appellate Division April 19, 1963 (FIRST SAV. & LOAN ASSN. OF JERSEY CITY v. Heldman)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-04-1963

79 N.J. Super. 65 (1963) 190 A.2d 400 THE FIRST SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSOCIATION OF JERSEY CITY, N.J., PLAINTIFF, v. WILLIAM HELDMAN AND MARGARET A. HELDMAN, HIS WIFE, DEFENDANTS. Superior Court of New Jersey, Bergen County Court, Law Division. Decided April 19, 1963. Mr. Edward J. Bogart for the plaintiff (Mr. Emil W.A. Schumann, attorney). No appearance by or for defendants. G.H. BROWN, J.C.C. The plaintiff has brought this attachment suit to collect the balance owing on an installment promissory note. The instrument provides for "reasonable *66 attorney's fees if collected by law or through an attorney at law." Because the defendants have not appeared in the action, an application for entry of a default judgment is before the court. The question is whether an attorney's fee should be allowed therein. The instrument is labelled "Property Improvement Note," but the format and provisions are in customary form for ordinary commercial paper. A judgment which included an attorney's fee was affirmed per curiam in Nash, etc., Inc. v. Consolidated Appliance Co., 12 N.J. Misc. 795, 174 A. 892 (Sup. Ct. 1934). The result simply rested on the fact that allowance of the fee was "in accordance with the contract in the notes." With equal aplomb the court in Gramatan Nat. Bank, etc., of Bronxville v. Backman, 30 N.J. Super. 349 (App. Div. 1954), implemented the consensual provision for an attorney's fee contained in the routine instrument. However, strong language by the Supreme Court in Bank of Commerce v. Markakos, 22 N.J. 428 (1956), has jarred confidence in the precedents cited. The law has been unsettled, in particular by the sweep of the Markakos observation that "In short, the purported right to contract as to counsel fees never existed in this state; any such attempt by private parties would have been struck down as against public policy quite as much as it would if the Legislature had attempted to do so." (22 N.J., at p.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.