Supreme Court of Iowa June 11, 1963, 50989 (Iowa Development Co. v. Iowa State Highway Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1963

Thompson, J.

This is the second appeal by the defendant, hereinafter known as the commission, from awards made by the trial court in two cases consolidated for trial. Iowa Development Co. v. Iowa State Highway Commission, and Emma C. Murphy v. Iowa State Highway Commission, 252 Iowa 978, 108 N.W.2d 487. Each trial was to the court sitting as the trier of the law and the facts and without a jury. The background facts are fully stated in the opinion on the first appeal, and will not be repeated here. Upon the first appeal we' reversed because of the admission of incompetent evidence.

No- jury demand was made before the first trial. But when the case was remanded, the defendant-commission filed a demand for a trial by jury, which was denied. The case was first tried by Judge Dring D. Needham; the second time by Judge Ralph R. Randall, with whose orders and awards we are concerned on this appeal.

I. The defendant’s first assigned error is based upon the refusal of the trial court to grant its application for a jury trial upon the remand. No application having been made before the first trial, the application was not timely. Rubin Brothers Butter & Egg Co. v. Larson, 247 Iowa 541, 542-545 inclusive, 74 N.W.2d 574, 575, 576. The failure here to make timely demand before the first trial distinguishes the Rubin case from Nedrow v. Michigan-Wisconsin Pipe Line Co., 246 Iowa 1075, 70 N.W.2d 843, where such a demand had been made.

The defendant maltes some contention that its application should have been granted under R. C. P. 177(d), which provides that even when application-is not timely made the court may in its discretion and for good cause shown order a jury

*295

trial. It is doubtful whether any real attempt was made here to show good cause. It is suggested that the defendant might be prejudiced by a trial to a different Judge of the same court because he would be reluctant to differ with the holdings of his associate made on the first trial.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.