Supreme Court of New Hampshire December 30, 1963, 5172 (Kelley v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1963

Kenison, C.J.

In this jurisdiction there is no statutory provision regulating the descent and distribution of property from the decedent to the slayer. Rees, American Wills Statutes II, 46 Va. L. Rev. 856, 888-889 (1960); Wade, Acquisition of Property by Willfully Killing Another — A Statutory Solution, 49 Harv. L. Rev. 715 (1936). Nor has the problem been presented in the case law of this state. Annot. 39 A.L.R. 2d 477. But, even in the absence of statute, a court applying common-law techniques can reach a sensible solution by charging the spouse, heir or legatee as a constructive trustee of the property where equity and justice demand it. 4 Scott, Trusts (2d

ed.

1956)

s.

492; Bogert, Trusts and Trustees,

s.

478 (2d

ed.

1960). Although the Restatement, Restitution,

s.

187,

comment

e has stated that this rule would not apply to manslaughter,

*242

the cases generally have not followed this limitation as applied to voluntary manslaughter. 4 Scott, Trusts (2d

ed.

1956)

s.

492.3, note 4;

Chase

v. Jenifer, 219 Md. 564;

Abbey

v.

Lord,

168 Cal. App. 2d 499. If the killing is intentional and unlawful, a constructive trust may be imposed upon the slayer whether his crime be denominated murder or voluntary manslaughter in those cases where it can be found that the slayer has been unjustly enriched by his criminal act. Bolich, Acts Barring Property Rights, 40 N.C. L. Rev. 175, 194(1962). That brings us to the question whether the husband in the circumstances of this case can inherit the property of his wife and retain its benefits.

Counsel for the husband contends that the statutes defining the rights of a surviving spouse (RSA 560:12, 13) and regulating descent and distribution (RSA ch. 561) are exclusive and courts are powerless to imply an exception in those situations where property is acquired by homicide.

Bird

v.

Plunkett,

139 Conn. 491;

Eversole

v.

Eversole,

160 Ky. 793.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.