California Court of Appeal December 10, 1963, Civ. 27322 (Brunt v. Occidental Life Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-12-1963
LILLIE, J.
Plaintiff sought a declaratory decree that defendant be held liable under a sickness and accident insurance policy for which he applied on August 21, 1961. At that time he tendered the sum of $5.46 and was given a receipt therefor, made subject to certain conditions. Eight days later, before the policy issued, he sustained a broken pelvis when he fell down a flight of steps. Judgment was for plaintiff after trial on a written stipulation of facts, and defendant has appealed. The single problem presented is whether the conditional receipt given to plaintiff created a contract of interim insurance pending acceptance of the application or approval of the risk.
Plaintiff has not filed a brief on appeal. His trial counsel, by letter, state that their client is an indigent and without funds to finance an appearance in this court; they further state that plaintiff’s actual pecuniary interest in the outcome of the instant litigation is so small that he would never consider expending the sums required. Without wishing to censure counsel, sometimes the economies of the situation must yield to the truism that, “ [lit is as much the duty of the respondent to assist the court upon the appeal as it is to properly present a ease, in the first instance, in the court below”
(Mosher
v.
Johnson,
51 Cal.App. 114, 116 [196 P. 84]); particularly is this true when respondent’s counsel recognize (as here) that “an issue of substantial public interest” is involved. With that observation, we pass to the merits.
The following facts were stipulated: On or about August 21, 1961, plaintiff applied to defendant for the policy in question. He tendered the amount equivalent to the first month’s premium “of such proposed policy, if as and when
*181
the same might be issued.” Defendant thereupon issued its written receipt for said payment, and plaintiff accepted the same.
The subject receipt reads as follows:
“Received from William Sidney Brunt, Applicant, the sum of $5.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit