California Court of Appeal March 5, 1963, Civ. 20039 (Pratt v. Western Pacific Railroad)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-03-1963
AGEE, J.
Defendant appeals from a judgment of $5,280, entered upon an adverse jury verdict in a personal injury action brought by a passenger riding on a free pass in a single, self-propelled diesel passenger unit known as a “Budd car.” Defendant also appeals from an order denying its motion for judgment notwithstanding the verdict. The unit is hereafter referred to as “the train.”
The pass had on its back a printed notice under which plaintiff had affixed her signature. This provided that the holder (plaintiff), by accepting the pass, “agrees to assume all risk of accident and damage to person or baggage in any circumstances and absolves The Western Pacific Railroad Company from all liability therefor.”
The trial court held that appellant could, by such an agreement, exempt itself from liability for its negligence but could not do so for its
gross
negligence.
Walther
v.
Southern Pac. Co.,
159 Cal. 769, 772-774 [116
*575
P. 51, 37 L.R.A. N.S. 235], is direct authority for this holding as applied to intrastate trips. The rule as to interstate trips is different, being controlled by federal law.
(Donnelly
v.
Southern Pac. Co.,
18 Cal.2d 863, 867-868 [118 P.2d 465] ;
Francis
v.
Southern Pac. Co.,
333 U.S. 445, 450 [68 S.Ct. 611, 92 L.Ed. 798].) The trip being made by respondent was intrastate.
In
Walther, supra,
the employee involved therein was riding on a free pass which was issued to him “in accordance with the long-established practice of the company ... to furnish passes from time to time to its employees. ’ ’ The Supreme Court held that a contract of exemption from liability for negligence is valid in such a situation but that section 2175 of the Civil Code "expressly prohibits limitations of liability for gross negligence on the part of the common carrier or his servants, whatever, as we read the various sections bearing upon this matter, may be the terms upon which it receives and undertakes to carry a passenger. ’ ’ (P. 774.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit