California Court of Appeal February 18, 1963, Civ. 20728 (Lundblade v. Phoenix)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-1963

MOLINARI, J.

This is an appeal from an order setting aside a default judgment in a quiet title action.

Question on Appeal

Was there substantial evidence to support the trial court’s order ?

The Record

On March 7, 1957, the plaintiff filed an action to quiet title to real property against two named defendants, George E. Phoenix and Natural Resources, Inc., a corporation. Pursuant to an affidavit, an order was made on May 24, 1957, that service be made on said defendants by publication. Thereafter, on February 24, 1958, a decree quieting title against both defendants was made and entered. On February 8, 1962, Jean Cantrell, as administratrix of the estate of George E. Phoenix, filed a notice of motion to set aside the default and the default judgment entered against George E. Phoenix. Concurrently with said motion the said Jean Cantrell filed an affidavit in support of said motion. The said affidavit is set out in its entirety in the footnote.

1

No counteraffidavit was filed by the plaintiff. The motion came

*110

on for hearing on February 26, 1962, at which time a certified copy of a certificate of death of one George Phoenix was presented to the court and filed. This certificate was certified by the County Recorder of Santa Barbara County. The said certificate recited, among other things, that a person named George Phoenix died on August 2, 1928, in the City of Santa Barbara, California. Thereafter, on March 9, 1962, the trial court made its ruling granting the motion,

2

pursuant to which an order was made and filed on March 19, 1962, setting aside the judgment.

3

The plaintiff appeals from the said order and from the ruling on the motion.

4

*109

"

1. That she is the administratrix of the Estate of George E. Phoenix, deceased, and that she has been duly appointed and is the presently acting administratrix.

“2.

That George E. Phoenix died in Santa Barbara, California, on August 2, 1928.

“3.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.