Wisconsin Supreme Court February 13, 1963 (Tyler v. State Department of Public Welfare)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-02-1963
Fairchild, J.
1.
Timeliness of proceedings for review.
The attorney general points out that there has been no formal refusal to parole petitioner, within thirty days before service of his petition for review or at any other time. In view of our conclusion that refusal to parole is not reviewable
*168
under secs. 227.15 to 227.21, Stats., inclusive, it is unnecessary to determine whether the present proceedings would be timely.
2.
Do secs. 227.15 to 227.21, Stats., inclusive, authorise proceedings to review a refusal to parole?
Sec. 227.15, Stats., provides in pertinent part:
“Administrative decisions, which directly affect the legal rights, duties, or privileges of any person, whether affirmative or negative in form, . . . shall be subject to judicial review as provided in this chapter.”
Decisions of the Department of Public Welfare are not excepted.
1
Thus the basic question is whether a prisoner’s interest in being paroled is a legal right or privilege within the meaning of sec. 227.15, Stats. If not such legal right or privilege, an administrative decision not to parole is not reviewable under sec. 227.15 ff.
Statutory and administrative provisions for parole.
Sec. 57.06 (1) (a), Stats., provides:
“The department [of public welfare] may parole an inmate of the Wisconsin state prison . . . when he has served twenty years of a life term, less the deduction earned for good conduct as provided in sec. 53.11. . . .”
The statutes contain no provisions fixing standards upon fulfilment of which an inmate is entitled to be paroled, although there are two conditions, in addition to service of a specified portion of the sentence, which must be met before the department is authorized to parole.
2
*169
There are no statutory provisions governing the application for parole nor requiring a hearing thereon. The statutes do not provide for a parole board.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit