Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court November 5, 1963 (Kaczmarski v. Mayor of Springfield)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-11-1963

Whittemore, J.

The mayor of Springfield and Leroy Clayborne have appealed from an order of the Superior Court which directs the issuance of a writ of mandamus to cancel and annul both the removal by the mayor of the petitioner as a member of the board of park commissioners and the mayor’s appointment of Clayborne to that post. The removal and appointment occurred on March 15,1962, without city council action.

The order is based on the ruling that Gr. L. c. 45, § 2, is applicable. That section provides:

‘ ‘

The mayor of a city may, with the approval of the city council, appoint a board of park commissioners for said city .... A commissioner may be removed ... by a vote of two thirds of all the members of a city council.”

The mayor acted under Gr. L. c. 43, §§52 and 54, which are a part of Springfield’s Plan A (“responsible executive” —

*433

1915 Senate Doc. No. 254, p. 23) charter. That charter was adopted by the city to be effective on the first Monday of January, 1962; it superseded the charter of St. 1852, c. 94 (as amended). Section 52 provides: “Upon the adoption of Plan A, all heads of departments and members of municipal boards, except the school committee, officials appointed by the governor, and assessors if elected by vote of the people, as their terms of office expire, shall be appointed by the mayor without confirmation by the city council. ’ ’ Removal power is set out in § 54: “The mayor may remove the head of a department or member of a board by filing a written statement with the city clerk setting forth in detail the specific reasons therefor, a copy of which shall be delivered or mailed to the person thus removed, who may make a written reply, which, if he desires, may be filed with the city clerk; but such reply shall not affect the action taken unless the mayor so determines. This section shall not apply to the school committee, or to officials appointed by the governor, or to assessors if elected by the people.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.