Appellate Court of Illinois October 23, 1963, Gen. 48,888 (Dale Jewelers, Inc. v. Walker)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-10-1963
MR. JUSTICE DEMPSEY
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is a garnishment action wherein the judgment against the garnishee defendant was vacated because of a jurisdictional defect, three years and ten months after it was entered. The plaintiffs appeal from the order vacating the judgment.
The garnishee defendant’s motion to dismiss the appeal, which was taken with the case, is denied.
In June 1958, the plaintiff, Dale Jewelers, Inc., judgment creditor of Robert Walker, filed a garnishment proceeding against Morton Balch, doing business as Balch Realty Management Co. Summons was issued and served. Morton Balch filed no appearance and a default judgment in garnishment was entered against him in favor of Walker, for the use of Dale Jewelers in the amount of $307.25. In February 1962, Balch moved to vacate the judgment for the reason that no affidavit in garnishment was filed at the commencement of the proceeding.
The parties agree that the affidavit was not in the court files at the time of the motion, that there was no record of it and that it had not been noted on the “half sheet” of the case, which is a document on which the motions, orders and proceedings of cases in the Municipal Court are listed for ready reference. There also is no dispute that such an affidavit is a jurisdictional requisite and that a void judgment may be vacated at any time. The dispute, rather, is whether the affidavit was filed when the garnishment proceeding was started, whether the plaintiff pursued the proper course to correct the record and whether the court was correct in vacating the judgment and denying the motion to correct the record.
The plaintiff filed an answer to the motion of the garnishee defendant to vacate the judgment and attached to the answer were the affidavits of the plaintiff’s attorney, his law clerk and a deputy clerk of the Municipal Court.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit