District Court, S.D. Texas June 11, 1963, Civ. A. 1515 (Sun Oil Company v. Martin)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-06-1963

*619

GARZA, District Judge.

On September 29, 1958, the Railroad Commission of Texas granted to Defendant Harry L. Martin permission to triply complete the McKinsey, et ah, Well No. 1 in the Shepherd Field, Hidalgo County, Texas. As completed, the lower tubing of this well was to produce oil and gas from the McKinsey Sand reservoir, the upper tubing was to produce gas from the Mellinger Sand reservoir, and the casing was to produce gas from the Martin Sand reservoir.

A packer setting affidavit and results of a packer leakage test were furnished the Railroad Commission to show compliance with its rules prohibiting communication of gas from two different reservoirs within the bore of a single well.

The well was produced under monthly allowables granted by the Railroad Commission, until January 15, 1962.

Plaintiff, Sun Oil Company, contends that all of the gas produced through the casing annulus, instead of being from the Martin Sand, was in fact from the Mellinger Sand which had leaked around the packer set in the well bore.

Plaintiff alleges that the gas produced from November 1, 1958, until January 15, 1962, through this McKinsey Well No. 1-C was produced in violation of statewide Rules 15 and 22 of the Railroad Commission which prohibit the producing of oil or gas from different reservoirs through the same casing or other producing string, and that such wrongful production amounted to a conversion of Plaintiff’s pro rata share of the total gas in place in the Mellinger Sand reservoir.

The action is one for damages caused by Defendants’ alleged violation of said Railroad Commission rules, or for the value of its gas allegedly converted wrongfully and/or negligently by Defendants.

In a hearing before the Railroad Commission on October 25, 1961, Plaintiff contended that the packer in Defendants’ multiply completed McKinsey well was leaking, and requested that McKinsey Wells 1-C and 1-UT (the casing and.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.