District Court, S.D. California March 14, 1963, 62-985 (Dugan v. American Broadcasting Corporation)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-03-1963

CRARY, District Judge.

Defendants seek summary judgment in an action wherein the plaintiff prays for damages based on alleged infringement of copyright on his copyrighted “playlet” or sketch of a program entitled “OPPORTUNITY”, as set forth in full as Exhibit 1 to plaintiff’s first amended complaint. Exhibit 6 to the complaint appears to set forth an amplication of the basic idea outlined in Exhibit 1, though quite different. No attempt was made to copyright the sketch, Exhibit 6, and it is urged by defendants and conceded by plaintiff’s counsel that any relief sought as to use by defendants of an alleged expression of ideas from Exhibit 6, which is entitled “IT’S ME — IS THIS YOU”, would have to be sought by way of an action on common law rights for plagiarism or breach of contract but not available in this action.

The question involved is, do defendants’ television programs, referred to in more detail hereafter, which were broadcast through the facilities of defendant American Broadcasting Company, infringe plaintiff’s copyrighted sketch entitled “OPPORTUNITY”, Exhibit 1 to plaintiff’s first amended complaint. This question prompts the queries:

1. Do any similarities of ideas in defendants’ programs to plaintiff’s playlet involve similarities of ideas only or the embodiment of the expression of basic ideas of plaintiff’s copyrighted sketch.

2. Now that the allegedly infringing programs are before the court for comparison with plaintiff's copyrighted sketch, can it be said that the television programs of defendants are so dissimilar as to say as a matter of law there is “no substantial similarity at all.” Richards v. Columbia Broadcasting System, D.C., 161 F.Supp. 516 (1958) at page 519.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.