Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit April 18, 1963, 7087 (Imperial Paving Company, a Co-Partnership Composed of H. A. Hudkins and John W. Kelly v. Horn's Crane Service Company, a Corporation)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-04-1963
BREITENSTEIN, Circuit Judge.
This dispute arose out of a highway construction job. Appellant-defendant, Imperial Paving Company (Imperial), had a prime contract with the State of Colorado and gave an oral subcontract to appellee-plaintiff, Horn’s Crane Sex-vice Company (Horn), for crushed rock. The subcontract was terminated by mutual consent. Later, Imperial obtained certain equipment from Horn to finish the job. Horn sued, claiming nonpayment of the amount due under a settlement of the subcontract and nonpayment, for equipment rental and transportation-imperial counterclaimed, asserting failure of Horn to crush the required quantity of rock.
After trial without a jury, the court below found that, on the termination of the oral subcontract, the parties made a full, final, and good faith settlement which provided for payment of $25,000-to Horn by Imperial; that Horn was entitled to receive from Imperial the reasonable rental value of the equipment ■subsequently furnished plus the cost of transporting the equipment from Denver, Colorado, to the construction site) and that nothing was due Imperial under the counterclaim. Horn had judgment for $29,183.26 and Imperial has ap
*29
pealed. Jurisdiction is based on diversity.
The evidence shows an oral settlement of the subcontract followed by a letter from Imperial to Horn. The letter refers to the work subcontracted and to the sale by Horn of certain equipment to Imperial and then says:
“" * * It appears that you have performed all of the crushing and we have accepted delivery on the equipment.
“As soon as we have final acceptance from the Colorado Highway Dept, we will send you a check for Twenty five Thousand Dollars ($25,-000) which is the amount we now owe you.”
Imperial denies the settlement. At the time the letter was given, Horn had stockpiled quantities of rock and had been delayed by the inability of Imperial to use the rock.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit