Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit November 14, 1963, 20370_1 (United States v. Murphy J. Foster and Olive R. Foster)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-11-1963
BENJAMIN C. DAWKINS, Jr., District Judge.
This appeal tests the correctness of a judgment by the trial court wherein appellees prevailed in a tax refund suit. The question for decision is whether, in a case involving facts as here presented, proceeds from the sale of an oil payment
*
are to be treated as ordinary income or capital gain. Both the oil payment and a royalty interest were reserved' by the taxpayer (See fn. 1) when he executed a mineral lease, but only the oil’ payment subsequently was sold.
Murphy J. and Olive R. Foster brought this action for refund of income taxes and interest for the year 1955 amounting to-$1,517.38.
1
Taxpayer owned an undivided l/10th interest in Dixie Plantation, containing about 800 acres, in St. Mary Parish, Louisiana. July 1, 1955, he and. his co-owners executed an oil, gas and mineral lease upon all but 11.11 acres of the land to Chester Hunter, for a six-months primary term and so long thereafter as oil or gas was produced.
Taxpayer and his co-lessors received a bonus of $5,000, but they retained what, was termed a 10/24ths “royalty” interest, until $220,000 was paid, and thereafter a 5/24ths royalty.
2
On the same day this-lease was executed, the lessors sold to
*704
other parties what they described as a “royalty,” but which was limited to a payment of $110,000 out of 5/24ths of production.
3
The transfer was made subject to the Hunter lease. The assignors received $100,882.35 for the oil payment, of which taxpayer’s share was $10,088.23.
In his 1955 income tax return taxpayer treated this transaction as the sale of a capital asset held for more than six months. After an audit, the Internal Revenue Service disallowed capital gain treatment and determined that the proceeds were ordinary income subject to depletion allowance.
The District Court, however, in granting plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment (the parties having stipulated the facts), held that there had been a sale of a capital asset.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit