Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit November 19, 1963, 15269 (Aetna Life Insurance Company, Mary Presley Hayes and Mary Van Worsley Droke v. Betty J. Hayes)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-11-1963

SHACKELFORD MILLER, Jr., Circuit Judge.

On December 27, 1941, the Aetna Life Insurance Company issued a $5,000.00 policy of life insurance to Carlos L. Hayes, a lawyer and resident of Arkansas. The named beneficiaries were the insured’s mother, Mary Presley Hayes, and the insured’s fiancee at that time.

On June 20,1950, the insured executed, upon a form provided by the company, a request for change of beneficiary, which continued his mother as one of the two beneficiaries, but changed the other beneficiary from his fiancee to his niece, Mary Van Worsley Droke.

In May 1955 the insured married the defendant, Betty Jo Womack Hayes. In January 1956 the insured wrote to his insurance agent and requested that the company provide him with a change of beneficiary form. The company replied that it was against its policy to distribute blank forms and requested that the insured supply it with the name of the proposed new beneficiary. In August 1956 the insured supplied the company with this information and the company forwarded to him a form for his signature with the blanks filled in, constituting a formal request to the company to change one of the beneficiaries from his niece, Mary Van Worsley Droke, to “Betty Jo Womack Hayes, wife of the insured.” A covering letter advised the insured as follows:

“We enclose herewith change of beneficiary agreement forms in con

*760

nection with your above numbered policy, which if satisfactory kindly sign both forms, have your signature witnessed and return the forms to us together with the policy, in order that the change of beneficiary may be completed.”

On April 17, 1961, the insured died as a result of injuries received in an automobile accident on April 16, 1961.

The change of beneficiary form, above referred to, unsigned, was found by his widow in the insured’s dresser drawer. The insurance policy was found in a trunk in his mother’s home in Blythe-ville, Arkansas, which contained the insured’s personal papers and old letters.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.